Rekeying vs. Changing Locks: Which is Right for You?

Introduction

Security is paramount for any home or business owner. When it comes to protecting your property, your locks are your first line of defense. But what happens when you need to enhance your security? You're often faced with two options: rekeying your locks or changing them entirely. Understanding the difference between these two options is crucial for making the right decision for your specific needs and budget. Both approaches offer increased security, but they address different concerns. Choosing the correct method can save you money and provide the peace of mind you deserve. This guide will walk you through the ins and outs of rekeying and changing locks, helping you determine the best path forward for your property. A qualified Locksmith can assist you to figure out the best method.

Main Content

Let's delve deeper into the specifics of rekeying and changing locks to help you make an informed decision.

Rekeying: A Cost-Effective Solution

Rekeying involves altering the internal mechanism of a lock so that it works with a new key, while the existing lock hardware remains in place. Think of it as giving your lock a new "identity." This is achieved by replacing the pins or wafers inside the cylinder of the lock. The original key will no longer work after the rekeying process.

When to Consider Rekeying:

• Lost or Stolen Keys: If you've lost your keys or suspect they've been stolen, rekeying prevents unauthorized access.
• Moving into a New Home: Rekeying ensures that previous owners, contractors, or anyone else with access to the old keys can no longer enter your property.
• Tenant Turnover: If you're a landlord, rekeying after each tenant moves out is a vital security measure.
• Recent Break-in (No Damage): If a break-in attempt failed to damage the lock itself, rekeying can provide an extra layer of security.
• Budget Concerns: Rekeying is generally more affordable than replacing all your locks.

A Locksmith can rekey nearly any standard pin tumbler lock.

Pros of Rekeying:

• Cost-effective: Rekeying is significantly cheaper than replacing locks.
• Convenient: The existing hardware remains in place, minimizing installation time and effort.
• Eco-friendly: Rekeying reduces waste by reusing existing materials.
• Quick Solution: A Locksmith can often rekey multiple locks in a relatively short amount of time.

Cons of Rekeying:

• Doesn't Address Hardware Issues: If your locks are old, damaged, or malfunctioning, rekeying won't solve those problems.
• Limited Security Upgrade: Rekeying doesn't improve the security of the lock itself; it only changes the key that operates it.

Changing Locks: A Comprehensive Security Upgrade

Changing locks involves replacing the entire lock mechanism, including the doorknob, cylinder, and strike plate. This is a more comprehensive solution that provides a fresh start for your security system.

When to Consider Changing Locks:

• Damaged or Malfunctioning Locks: If your locks are difficult to operate, rusted, or show signs of wear and tear, replacement is necessary.
• Upgrading Security: Replacing old or standard locks with high-security models offers superior protection against picking, bumping, and forced entry. A Locksmith can give you some advice on what to choose.
• After a Break-in (Lock Damaged): If your locks have been damaged during a break-in, they need to be replaced.
• Aesthetic Upgrades: Replacing locks can also enhance the appearance of your doors and home.

Pros of Changing Locks:

• Enhanced Security: Offers the opportunity to upgrade to higher-security lock models.
• Addresses Hardware Issues: Solves problems with old, damaged, or malfunctioning locks.
• Aesthetic Improvement: Allows for a fresh, updated look for your doors.
• Peace of Mind: Provides a greater sense of security and protection.

Cons of Changing Locks:

• More Expensive: Replacing locks is generally more costly than rekeying.
• More Time-Consuming: Installation can take longer than rekeying, especially if you're replacing multiple locks.

Making the Right Choice: A Decision Guide

Consider the following questions to determine whether rekeying or changing locks is right for you:

1. What is your budget? Rekeying is the more economical option.
2. Are your locks in good working condition? If so, rekeying may be sufficient.
3. Do you need to upgrade your security? If so, changing locks and opting for high-security models is the best choice.
4. Have your locks been damaged? Damaged locks require replacement.
5. Do you simply need to prevent access from old keys? Rekeying is a cost-effective solution for this.

Remember, a professional Locksmith can assess your specific situation and provide personalized recommendations.

Need a Locksmith professional? We've got you covered.

Key Takeaways

• Rekeying changes the internal mechanism of a lock to work with a new key.
• Changing locks replaces the entire lock mechanism.
• Rekeying is more cost-effective and suitable for preventing access from old keys.
• Changing locks offers enhanced security and addresses hardware issues.
• Consider your budget, security needs, and the condition of your existing locks when making your decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

• How long does rekeying take? Rekeying a single lock typically takes 15-30 minutes per lock by a Locksmith.
• Can all locks be rekeyed? Most standard pin tumbler locks can be rekeyed.
• Is it cheaper to rekey or replace locks? Rekeying is almost always cheaper than replacing locks.
• What are high-security locks? High-security locks offer advanced features like drill resistance, pick resistance, and bump resistance.

Conclusion

Choosing between rekeying and changing locks depends on your individual needs and circumstances. Rekeying provides a cost-effective solution for preventing access from old keys, while changing locks offers a more comprehensive security upgrade. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide and consulting with a qualified Locksmith, you can make the right decision to protect your property and gain peace of mind. Ultimately, your security is worth the investment, and making an informed choice is the first step towards creating a safer environment.